CASE NO.:  CR 54/07

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NAMIBIA
In the matter between:
THE STATE

versus

1.	SHIMBWALE KASMIA
2.	NAURE TJIPITO

		(HIGH COURT REVIEW CASE NO.:  419/05)

CORAM:	  VAN NIEKERK, J et  SILUNGWE, AJ
Delivered on: 	 2007-03-29
REVIEW JUDGMENT:
VAN NIEKERK, J:	

[1]	The two accused were convicted by the Magistrate, Opuwo on a charge of housebreaking with intent to steal and theft of cash and goods to the value of ±N$4 220 stolen from a shop, most of which were not recovered.  I am satisfied that the conviction is in order.
2

[2]	The magistrate sentenced the accused to 8 years imprisonment of which 3 years were suspended for 5 years on the usual condition.  The sentence clearly exceeds the ordinary penalty jurisdiction of a magistrate's court in a case like this, which is, in the case of imprisonment, a maximum period of 5 years imprisonment.  The sentences can therefore not stand.

[3]	The personal circumstances of the accused as stated by themselves are that accused no. 1, who was about 28 years old, has a girl friend and four children.  He volunteered information that he was serving a number of sentences totaling seven years for various crimes, but no previous convictions were proved.  Before he went to prison he had 10-11 goats.  Accused no. 2, who was about 27 years old of age, had a girlfriend and two children.  He was unemployed, had no money for a fine and no live stock.

The loss sustained by the complainant is considerable.  The evidence also shows that a window, a door and burglar bars were broken in order to gain access to the shop, thereby adding to his damages.

3

[4]	I agree with the trial magistrate that an appropriate sentence in the circumstances of this case would be a substantial period of imprisonment of which part is suspended.

[5]	In the result the following order is made:

1.	The convictions of both accused are confirmed.

2.	The sentences of both accused are set aside and substituted by the following sentence:

4 (four) years imprisonment of which (one) year is suspended for 5 (five) years on condition that the accused is not convicted of housebreaking with intent to steal and theft committed within period of suspension.

______________________________
VAN NIEKERK, J

4

I agree

_______________________________
SILUNGWE, AJ