Court name
High Court Main Division
Case number
APPEAL 271 of 2013
Title

Alugodhi v Minister of Safety And Security and Others (APPEAL 271 of 2013) [2015] NAHCMD 160 (14 July 2015);

Media neutral citation
[2015] NAHCMD 160
Coram
Damaseb J
Miller AJ

PK YBõF^Æ2' ' mimetypeapplication/vnd.oasis.opendocument.textPK YBõF Configurations2/statusbar/PK YBõF ' Configurations2/accelerator/current.xml PK PK YBõF Configurations2/floater/PK YBõF Configurations2/popupmenu/PK YBõF Configurations2/progressbar/PK YBõF Configurations2/toolpanel/PK YBõF Configurations2/menubar/PK YBõF Configurations2/toolbar/PK YBõF Configurations2/images/Bitmaps/PK YBõF layout-cachecd`d(ØËÀÀÀÉÀÀ"cXƒ¼~@FT4&šd¸²@9@Ž6#TI#LIaÂåLr˜¡œ@N!”³ÈQ…Érr`N83éç\2.”¼2 PK¬b_c Á PK YBõF content.xmlí}ÛnɵèûùŠŽ‚½aԅ¤î“q@K²­KD9³çFPdɎ›ÝL_$+Où‡ó²°7¯8ó'ù’½.UÕՒMŠÔÈãI Ýì®ËZ«Ö}­úÿŒ}çNF±ßo4·w7ôC׆ßo|¸}½u´ñǗÿëá`àõå‰öÓ±’­~$ð_¾âþõû4
NB{ñI Æ2>Iú'áDú«û횋ŸÄɃ_ûszÙþ:‘_’ºã»¹oE¯þÌô²ýµ‰ûºã» TûóAX÷ã/±¿5êã‰H¼Â*¾ø^ðùûQ’LNvvîïï·ïÛÛa4ÜiïЯfÁ}óÞ$|zËíïH_âdñNs»¹£ßËDÔ]¾k/)HÇ=ՍHD «ñÝ°6EÜ
§€¦?QmÚ —óèm»õÑÛvíoÇ"MÁÉÑÎ%üH\¾Ëh!םß́ªy“ÚÛä·íïÃ04KÅø€Òr[»»{;üoëíû™¯ßG^"#ëõþÌ×ûÂã* Á{ÍxcKÞ!™ÂG@ÄS>híðÏæå؝:ô\¾ëöGr,²—½ù/oyAœˆ ƒL„H˜ºÓýHNÂ(1€Ôg˜€­–YÛ(ûӏ;þª_F®[ù*,§½GÞ֝'ïŸã‡³éáx‡^2„ëI_Ÿó®ÚŽü2‘‘‡;>ÂÖ8 q„“ëk¦Eõ¥%‹Z/µàa¢w̃ ­èË-Wöýø嘁˜Çÿ×ñýF'ò„ßÜp€Qè7ƞÿ ~h8±â­–:Øؙ=Ò©ð½^äU¥~Yd°K«×Å¿Ìûþ@;WòÞ¹ Ç"¨çßÅ$Œ¿+¼Ç7œÜÐøþÖP°n8®‘/{câ%}`hw †ØŸ³4ì4€Ïœ:¾÷âø1S+ØMêÌÉâDŽ5»×Â8$ÎÏâ­¬"á½8yüÚºÞ¸›V‘‰ùá±³ïL;ê¹H ¬ÄëoÑ8æØҟ¹µ^7Í\j‘‰a$ý¨wníþ¹ºzpóá֏ŒNà ÅHn¤7Ûn6÷ÿv`-hÆêZ¿Àêð)ê¯[Ài†À ANèÉþ’Ɖ7x؊AÄéîÃXò@ø±Eô©5‡õ”æJFQ˜G[JÂ@æÐ=…çÀ¢èçØûüÜlM’
{è4peDãWŒKoôPA%sƒlωƒn|A~èìGÔû|ùEý\íµ#ÐFè QòdÁxýÐA¥þý.ýïq¨Y3p÷žøtìï–OÇ7òýg råoèÏ@
|ct~ø@¾:_ÂúÙ½Z]/ôÝ'‚ûÑ3à/}cáë;¥®þ6•Š¯Íô}}´?´­DOý†pÖÜý–yܓp³æ/a]>‹sñ4à}jóxMÚèsñú
رˆ†^°•„“ï7v=Þ¬z֓]õúqO¥nV;âÐ÷Ü)¯Ü{.†fÐ5å
µ>š‘þþT8]¿Ý\§¿c¡¹~«ø«8$ëóúíàgC·¿  Ö\¿íûìÀ¬ø¹—€Pïÿ²Ð_¿¼4/Y,vÑ\¿Q¸v®8·0uŒ±µ~kñ9ÓéúµçD§OÓgn=ÏêÓ ãÉÌ*_ÂylD÷Ž‰7ŒÕ@ÊkCƒv+÷ãWŒ²'3Üe»ëAYÎë·ÊêêÉL¯ê› â'3ØÖJÅßãYÊÊë&"pEän|;^ÎČ?¤ÒӐ
Aâ•è+ÛÍãƒ}›AüÚ#%·%Ë×>‡Œøi{ åI·Ûÿæí.à ¸-)üËOZmöÕ_JIOž¹”GNVҟÌFüœ ñã¢À·%
¨ÖbéWã/«?[IXb¶Ç¢§$-ç­¡àj¬?S‰É/8ӓƞêo«ÄɗÛÖW﫽-gPü¢xš=/&J¾ªÓm9¡`ÑÍ¡V+‚a*†õ‰
~'
’ûߝEÖ²œÌ¢2 TŽƒ0cŠÖq’H1—ÿQnü+YN Õ^É£xl9öºâÅ=gr]Lœ>OiR7ÎCàªØÂâyæď֍Êñ²Ø|–tYI­a'sññ4[]ƲZùVI… ×©+3ô¿E¦ZX$¦z¤éЕý¤„ï‚­jV¡þ½¤Ç®§:F°ËA
ÛIǁÞüu‹È p¶a=Š‰ îL[TqÏ;SK'Õè'4ÿ@P;øÇIƒ x Î­^$Åçð¥¸jz#–MeÕh–òH®O|ñ°¦ _ÞI6²Á?3
.|?AFÈw9Ø­®'}Ü(HƒäŒÛvʦCmŸf¶LÅIJóë¯Þ]œ:ï_;WË‹W5Êdö‡o/Þ¼uN߸¹µ>u.;WÎÙş.ºï¯ÎOWgoߟÿXoÈ>œ½¹§ã´›;­Ýf»Þ‡gÛó§¹çüðáÝÏ|·_gÆVËPåDån÷6^^Àó‘tà$2rz2¹—28ÑhÏ^֘èpãeçêìæ¼Óu:ï>¼yööb漸°í'øŸ½Îõ5Mçê¶Æ~ÀÔ}Ù Üz;¿¼¸ºèޞß8¯ßß8ÝÎëó۟€†Ó=?ýpsqûóš aï­9sŽæÆËî­ýºssÞ½~uv^°ÅÓ÷——]#
sss~zÃÀçÝó›?]œžwŸ–Pl0´æAíêly¨! Í¿½ñòýë× ÐéÛÎ͛óŒý8§0
Bùúæ¢ûþ*wg¬=`µÇaÚõ'¦|¶ÈÐePÖå4ͦâ¢WÄEÛí½º\èïÍ9°þîÛÎuçêÍùúù
v°î³zûöÜy{Þ9Ãé§PÓÚ _aÈ!5@ÑëÎÕÅ9𕫯~1†íüóËýê‡_3^K€©â•µ’êá",xÎÚózóÈ3õÏ,Ã8{݋Ë÷WÎõùí͇®ó»7«óW«GþR2ƒb¾>.1c×ëæjø¼»ó,ØÇÊÁi~~,dÊ^Ÿ!i·a çg?unΜ;—¯>\}XJWNQ_™ò¡ó-é5€· |y6ñc¥¦QØÐ3d¨gì/À&Þ½ÿpÑuÞ8]Øó‡nwé3°Rô/üúóå‹ïúÛáKˆ>Y7‡°-÷ÜV_wN/Þ!æ5ر‡õ2µJ``7×ç7À¬€Ÿuo/n?¨¥¦ooÏÏa%/~z}ºYX$üsoÞoß®tDgjy7çïÎ;ÝsçÕ{PTæ {ë\šÓ6wsx!~ì\¼:µÉ¯ýL-0Ìóå·KlpÝwenõº
›Ë‚æBVÉ£÷‡÷Ý·:ÀpOßÞ®Ã+¤”š;#fsgaå;Y «k>j­åNZk¯¶ó¾öað_\^v®>œ¿sÞt^Ý\ÀŸð3Á?w
‹Òä"҆  ôCçú§Î“eAÀ-J«‹2'ñ-3§_ÚZZ9Ìrƒ?/?‹3‹Ì5¥"÷y^rN@!Ó$¾Ó÷Ê;±–W;Þ¾²ÞO‡¡;òœ;çÒ¼8‰œpàtÅ@&6§+ûiäÁ?ìa_tZ‡Í-äÿ›ÎGL:ú4øöôòÌiì:/0)õ(i³æŽkIˆÖá|М†‘çò”œ³Î%Øv¯Î׎LœË‹wïÎoNç‡a㭑{ⴎœKA»Þ[0y¡Î$gÒ÷îd$a"õ*¿×ÿ~£µ±ó҆¹³†é_ûA˜Hý“‰ïõ‰êróüëïÿÇ9“}_D" ‘Œ"WFNŒ—$pd¼À‰V¥ëôQ‹À·OÃñ$eúE¢‹±+FЗ±ãá¢qLO£ü/æ¢]G^±Óé'NóŸâýN@oø§õã&Qnþě Ôô¿”±¶vêT­£]=×i䍽 ŽØuö¥›FGnÀŒ‡‡Î\Á~“Wpx¸ùâôº³I{úi$áëȚ! (
ìÕøk9ðo“íD/Əp\Àƒü2‰d+H¢pL/%x©|žF Ž£fò‚¡z†ËèXӄöۃa›àîCg…wÞü;ÂV`™2„ÌŽïĀx{èï`b88‘œ¤Ã@ (á»0ÀBÚw69Ҁúʋ™ä§:‰ÄxQÐh8ÂÀö43 EÔ¤ÿõÓOÂXºÛÈ£ÂÀÅá¢2 ;xK¢ýÀŸ"’V`œqê'ÞÄÇ)‚;ƒã†§ý‘õ݄h›L†D Ñv·Û‘é™û`?âԂÖÀ_úrBNké=à¯iÓZ3BÔp/>3öA^†\zæ{‰{&:Ç[ž¹rð!ȌDÏKR p0X˜Ò@H ÿ^